
My dear friend sent me a message the other day. The conversation went like this:

The end of a year is a time to reflect. To reflect on the things you have done in the past year or years and things you have not yet accomplished. We all reflect back, whether this nostalgia is good or bad is up to the individual. This past year has seen a number of changes. We Americans have elected our first Black president. In a more centric aspect I have changed my life immensely. First I changed my major from Biology to Anthropology. Then I moved away from the town that I have lived in for my entire life, to start anew in a new town and at a new school. With the start of new school come new requirements for graduation, at my former university I had completed all the General Education that I needed for graduation. However I was disheartened to discover that although the classes and units themselves transferred the G.E. requirement did not.
At this point I guess you are wondering why I’m talking about G.E. requirements and all this life changing stuff. Well the G.E. theme that I chose is the Cross-Cultural theme. Apart of this theme is the Multi-Cultural Literature class that I have been writing all these blogs for over the past few months. As the semester winds down and the end approaches very quickly, we have come to our final blog. Over the past few weeks we have been discussing globalization, specifically Franklin Foer’s book How Soccer Explains the World. But I wonder how this book relates to the other books we have read through out this semester and to the bigger picture as well. Can globalization help us to better understand people from other nations; can knowing their stories help us to better understand ourselves?

America has learned a lot and has a lot to learn from the rest of the world. We are not unique and our ideas are not new. Globalism is shrinking our world, any day of the week one can simply purchase a plane ticket and fly to any part of the world you wish to visit. You can see the local sites, taste the local cuisine and engage in any number of other activities. Above all you get to know other people and their culture and they get to know you. This concept is exceptionally portrayed in Perry Garfinkel’s book Buddha or Bust. This author although American goes on an international journey to visit all the important Buddhist sights. He and many who have also gone on similar journeys to other countries are affected by the things they see and the people that they meet. This gives them a feeling of being included in the bigger picture, part of a globalcommunity.
In every country that Garfinkel visits he sees a different way of practicing Buddhism. That’s not to say that one way is better than another, but the fact that it came from one origin and has spread to so many different countries and incorporated itself into their traditions shows that maybe Buddhism was an early form of globalization. The sharing of ideas and the learning of different ways of thinking can benefit a society in ways it could have never imagined. We Americans can sometimes think we are better than the rest of the world that some how our way is the best and will continue to be the best. However many Americans are now starting to follow Buddhism and they see the benefits of this more peaceful way of thinking.
I fell strongly that America as well as the rest of the world would benefit from learning the ways of Ubuntu, (my humanity is strengthened by embracing your humanity). This concept is the basis for the book A Human Being Died that Night by Pumla Gobodo-Msdikizela. This telling of the process of reconciliation that South Africa went through after the end of apartheid is inspiring. It should give us all hope that even the most evil deeds committed by the most evil people has the possibility of being put behind us, so that we may move forward. I wish that South Africa had learned from America the pitfalls of a separated society, so that the people who died and suffered wouldn’t have had to do so for so long. So that men like Eugene de Kock wouldn’t have been forced to make the decision whether or not to become a killer for their country. I wish that the global society could havedone something to help them long before the 1990s.
As our world gets smaller in the access we have to people and things from around the world at our fingertips, we must also learn from their mistakes and accomplishments. The human species is not perfect in any way. But we should also not turn a blind eye to the atrocities that go on in our neighboring countries. We as human beings are constantly trying to evolve to be a better version of our selves. If we cannot learn from our mistakes and those of others than we can never move forward. We will stagnate in our never ending quest to be the best that we can be.
In the final chapter of How Soccer Explains the World Foer delves into the notion that the split in American feeling about soccer also explains the spilt in the attitudes about globalization. “One camp believes in the essential tenets of the globalization religion as preached by European politicians, that notional governments should defer to institutions like the UN and WTO” (Foer 245). “On the other side, there is a group that believes in ‘American exceptionalism,’ an idea that America’s history and singular form of government has given the nation a unique role to play in the world; that the U.S. should be above submitting to international laws and bodies” (Foer 234).
I am not here to say which side is better. I believe that America has a lot to offer the rest of the world but also that the rest of the world has a lot to offer America. We as a species need to see that we are all one people that national boundaries while important are also arbitrary. Until we learn that we are really all the same there will always be wars and people will always be in conflict with each other over philosophical differences. In the end we just all need to learn how to get along and figure out bigger global issues like the environment rather than bicker about petty differences. I’ll leave you with my favorite quote from How Soccer Explains the World it shows the absurdity of some peoples way of thinking, how can a sport threaten a way of life?
“People with actual power believe that soccer represents a genuine threat to the American way of life.”
List of the Books we Read This Semester
Photos found at the following:
Globalization is “the tendency of investment funds and businesses to move beyond domestic and national markets to other markets around the globe, thereby increasing the interconnectedness of different markets. Globalization has had the effect of markedly increasing not only international trade, but also cultural exchange” (Answers.com).
“Globalization (or globalisation) in its literal sense is the process of transformation of local or regional phenomena into global ones. This process is a combination of economic, technological, sociocultural and political forces. Globalization is often used to refer to economic globalization, that is, integration of national economies into the international economy through trade, foreign direct investment, capital flows, migration, and the spread of technology” (wikipedia.org).
Now that we know a little about what globalization is all about lets shift to soccer. You may be asking your self what soccer has to do with globalization. But this is exactly what Franklin Foer does in How Soccer Explains The World. Foer uses soccer to explain globalization. As a soccer fan he could see globalization on the pitch. “During the nineties, Basque teams, under the stewardship of Welsh coaches, stocked up on Dutch and Turkish players; Moldavian squads imported Nigerians” (pp 2-3). This had never before taken place, this sweeping away of national borders and identities for teams to get the best players. But as much as most teams were incorporating people from outside their country to play on their national teams there were some countries out there who were not.
One example of this comes from Serbia. “The Red Star Belgrade is the most beloved, most successful soccer team in Serbia” (pg 7). Like nearly all clubs in Europe and Latin America, it has a following of violent fans. However these fans are renowned for being the most violent. These fan gangs organize with the club officials, and their leaders receive stipends and accesses to office space at the team’s headquarters. One incident a few months before the author arrive in Belgrade the Red Star fan clubs burst into the teams training session and beat three of their own players. When asked by the press why they did it they replied that they could “no longer tolerate lack of commitment on the pitch” (pg 8).
On the authors arrival he set out to interview a handful of them. He meet with a man named Draza, a leader of a Red Star fan club that calls itself the Ultra Bad Boys. Six others joined them, including a man named Krle. “Krle serves as a senior advisor to the group, a mentor to the aspiring hooligans” (pg 9). He was an active member during the time of Foer’s interest in this team “when the fan clubs played a pivotal role in the revival of Serbian nationalism” (pg 9). Krle is not interested in speaking to an American, and stops taking to Foer at the mention of Arkan, a man they call commandant. As the interview continues the younger ones regale Foer with their tales of beating up opposing teams’ fans with metal bars and wooden bats. But they conceder themselves on the higher moral ground than their foes for they don’t use firearms and stop the beating when the personloses consciousness.
“During the thirty-five years the communist Marshal Tito ruled Yugoslavia, he had suppressed bad feelings over World War II, simply declaring the expression of such feeling illegal” (pg 15). The country had never come to terms with the fact that its two largest constituents had slaughtered one another. They used soccer as a means to express themselves legally. With the dissolving of communism the old wounds were reopened, both Serbs and Croats began to demand justice for the crimes the other committed. This enmity could be seen at the soccer stadium. “In matches between Serb and Croat teams, fans sang about their respective slaughters” (pg 16).
In 1990, the Red Star Belgrade traveled to Croatia for a match against the rival club Dinamo Zagreb. This was the first time in fifty years that Yugoslavia had seen its ethnic groups openly battle one another. At first the trouble seemed manageable, even typical of any European game. Then the Dinamo fans started throwing rocks as the Red Star fans used billboards as shields. Then the fences that separated them mysteriously disappeared and a brawl engulfed the entire stadium. It was evident that both sides came ready for a fight. Guarding the Red Star coach from the violence was a secret-police hit man called Zeljko Raznatovic, also known as Arkan.
In 1991, the team won the European Champions Cup. This team despite its history as a vehicle for Serb nationalism had included players from across the country of Yugoslavia. In spite of this multi-ethnic Yugoslavian achievement the destruction of this nation was being plotted in the Red Star’s headquarters. “The Red Star fans would become Milosevic’s shock troops, the most active agents of ethic cleansing, highly efficient practitioners of genocide” (pg 13).
Arkan was the leader of the paramilitary force, primarily composed of Red Star fans. Arkan called his army the Tigers; it immediately began to earn its notorious reputation. “Arkan waged some his bloodiest offensives near the Bosnian town of Sasina” (pg 23). He sent our his Tigers on patrols to detain Muslim men, evict their families, and loot their homes (pg 23). By the end of the war in Croatia and Bosnia, according to State Department estimates, with throat slitting, strangulation, and other forms of execution, Arkan’s Tigers had killed at least 2,000 men and women (pg 24). He was turned into a hero by the Serbs. In the end he was gunned down in the lobby of the Intercontinental Hotel, there are many theories as to why he was killed, but we may never know the exact reason why.
Images found at:
Another option for our blogs this week was to write a letter to Eugene de Kock. I struggled with this one. I felt that I should write to him. That it would be an experience that was likely not to be repeated. I mean when in our lives do we ever get the opportunity to confront our fears in the most basic sense. It’s like Pumla Gonbodo-Madolozela said in a Human Being died That Night. “It is this sense of a paper-thin line that is most frightening and most discomforting about those moments when our lives connect, however remotely, with the lives of people who have committed evil deeds.” (p. 50)
I wanted to write to him. But what could I say. Where does my morality lay? Am I one who would throw away the key and say that he is evil and will always be evil, or am I in the camp that allows for redemption. I truly do not know. How can I be this arrogant person, so far removed from all of the happenings in South Africa, as to think that I can make this decision even for my own opinion? I tried to ask myself how I would feel if de Kock had killed the people in my town, in my neighborhood, in my family. But I can not even imagine the pain. Would I want revenge or would I need to forgive? Could I even make a conscious decision either way?
After reading Pumla’s book, I can see the good side of de Kock. Or at least that is what is presented to us. The book is not necessarily pro de Kock, but most definitely pro forgiveness of him and his deeds. It shows us all how easily a government can turn its back on its most heinous actions and wash their hands of it. Lay all the blame on the “foot soldiers”. I hope to never be in the position that de Kock was in. I would like to think that I would pass the test of my humanity with flying colors, that I would rather die that abuse others, but in reality I pray to God that I am never tested.
I guess my real question is why the Truth and Reconciliation committee pardoned de Kock on all his many crimes except two murders. This really bothers me. Was this just a compromise? To show that they were all about reconciliation but also to make sure that de Kock went behind bars to satisfy those who could not forgive. Or where these two murders not politically motivated and de Kock stepped outside his role as the enforcer of his government’s secret war and became the evil that some people believe he is. What is it about these two murders that set them apart from the rest?
If I were to write de Kock I would ask him about those murders. Why does he feel that he was not pardoned for these particular crimes? I would ask him if he feels that he deserves to be pardoned for all his crimes or if part of him believes he deserves what he has been handed in life. And I finally would like to know if he was released from prison would he ever feel safe in South Africa knowing that there are people out there that probably wouldn’t want him released and could possibly harm him for revenge of the crimes he committed.
This indecision of mine is right out of Shakespeare. To write de Kock or to not write de Kock, plagues my mind. So I leave the letter writing to those of us who are braver and more eloquent than I to express themselves to de Kock, and thus is the reason for the above blog.
The question of apartheid of the mind, how does the average citizen come to terms with the atrocities that were done in their name. Did they really not know are their hands clean, or were they just diluting themselves into thinking that their government was really just trying to keep them safe from communism? The whole idea of apartheid is the compartmentalization of South African thinking. “There were two South Africas: White and Black. Similarly, there was the public world and a private world, the open and the covert” (p. 108). All of this was rigidly separated. The white South African bystanders were able to live with the brutality against blacks because it was carried out in relative secret (p. 109). It was only when the truth came out that some people could not live with it, but then the silence wasmaintained for the greater good (p. 109).

In the book A Human Being Died that Night, Pumla Gonbodo-Madolozela’s goes on a road trip with her sister to see the infamous Vlakplaas. Vlakplaas is a farm just outside of Pretoria, also known as the death farm, where Eugene de Kock and his cronies did some of their crimes during apartheid. Pumla drove there using a map that de Kock had drawn for her in one of her meetings with him at the prison. However, as her sister pointed out, they were getting lost with his directions. The question arises as to whether or not he really wanted to give her the directions, for her to be able to go and see the place where he committed deeds that he his now deeply sorry for, the possibility that her visiting this place would make his crimes more real for her and sway her to the position of not seeing him as a humanworthy of forgiveness. Or he could just be really bad at giving directions.

Either way they had to stop and ask for directions. Pumla “approached a young woman behind the cash register and asked if she could please direct us to Vlakplaas” (p. 104). The young woman asked back “You mean the Vlakpaas?” with a nervous laugh, then she points to the older woman whom she had been speaking to. The older woman explained that her and her sister often walked through one section of the farm. “But they knew nothing about what had gone on during those early years – about what had now come out in the papers” (p.105). In fact this lady with a heavy German accent and her sister wished to buy a whole section of Vlakplaas, and turn it into a game reserve. She knew there were still bodies buried there but she believes that the beauty of deer frolicking wouldgive them a chance to rest in peace. How could these women not know what had gone on there? They were their neighbors, how could they have not seen or heard something to even hint at the dark deeds that were going on in side. I guess sometimes we humans don’t even see what is right in front of us, unless we are ready to accept the consequences.

This lack of knowledge is reiterated as Pumla and her sister drove through the final suburb before reaching Vlakpaas. She stopped and asked an Indian couple standing in their garden for directions to Vlakpaas. They told her that they “never heard of it” (p.106). They were literally seven minutes away and these people had never heard of it either as the death farm or as a legitimate farm. How could these people never hear of their grizzly neighbor? It was probably the only way they can cope with all that has happened, to make it apart from them. If they know nothing about it, then they could not have done something to stop it.

Finally Pumla arrived at the section of Vlakpaas that she was seeking. It was sealed off behind a tall fence with a large gate, a pack of bulldogs charged aggressively. A woman stood back as a young black man approached them. They told Pumla that she had to make an appointment to come and visit, nothing left to do she left.
These ordinary citizens were not the only ones who have separated out their existence from the atrocities that was done in their name. The man who came to be known as “Prime Evil”, Eugene de Kock also possesses this apartheid of the mind. Of separating out his family life from the work he did at Vlakpaas and the over boarder raids. He tells Pumla “It was hell. But they never knew” (p. 107). He talks about being afraid all the time, caring a firearm with him at all times even when he was out with his family. “I was afraid of my own people, my own people, because now they knew where I was, where I worked, when I left home, and where I would be at a specific time (pp 107-108). His children thought he was a business man, for they never saw him in a uniform like the otherpolicemen that they saw. To this day de Kock won’t divulge where his wife and children have relocated to, to protect them. For when your roles are reversed, according to de Kock “What has happened to your enemy can happen to you if you become the enemy” (p. 107)
Images found at the following:
**********************************************************************