Sunday, November 16, 2008

To write de Kock or to not write de Kock?

Another option for our blogs this week was to write a letter to Eugene de Kock. I struggled with this one. I felt that I should write to him. That it would be an experience that was likely not to be repeated. I mean when in our lives do we ever get the opportunity to confront our fears in the most basic sense. It’s like Pumla Gonbodo-Madolozela said in a Human Being died That Night. “It is this sense of a paper-thin line that is most frightening and most discomforting about those moments when our lives connect, however remotely, with the lives of people who have committed evil deeds.” (p. 50)

I wanted to write to him. But what could I say. Where does my morality lay? Am I one who would throw away the key and say that he is evil and will always be evil, or am I in the camp that allows for redemption. I truly do not know. How can I be this arrogant person, so far removed from all of the happenings in South Africa, as to think that I can make this decision even for my own opinion? I tried to ask myself how I would feel if de Kock had killed the people in my town, in my neighborhood, in my family. But I can not even imagine the pain. Would I want revenge or would I need to forgive? Could I even make a conscious decision either way?

After reading Pumla’s book, I can see the good side of de Kock. Or at least that is what is presented to us. The book is not necessarily pro de Kock, but most definitely pro forgiveness of him and his deeds. It shows us all how easily a government can turn its back on its most heinous actions and wash their hands of it. Lay all the blame on the “foot soldiers”. I hope to never be in the position that de Kock was in. I would like to think that I would pass the test of my humanity with flying colors, that I would rather die that abuse others, but in reality I pray to God that I am never tested.

I guess my real question is why the Truth and Reconciliation committee pardoned de Kock on all his many crimes except two murders. This really bothers me. Was this just a compromise? To show that they were all about reconciliation but also to make sure that de Kock went behind bars to satisfy those who could not forgive. Or where these two murders not politically motivated and de Kock stepped outside his role as the enforcer of his government’s secret war and became the evil that some people believe he is. What is it about these two murders that set them apart from the rest?

If I were to write de Kock I would ask him about those murders. Why does he feel that he was not pardoned for these particular crimes? I would ask him if he feels that he deserves to be pardoned for all his crimes or if part of him believes he deserves what he has been handed in life. And I finally would like to know if he was released from prison would he ever feel safe in South Africa knowing that there are people out there that probably wouldn’t want him released and could possibly harm him for revenge of the crimes he committed.

This indecision of mine is right out of Shakespeare. To write de Kock or to not write de Kock, plagues my mind. So I leave the letter writing to those of us who are braver and more eloquent than I to express themselves to de Kock, and thus is the reason for the above blog.

Sunday, November 9, 2008

Apartheid of the Mind

The question of apartheid of the mind, how does the average citizen come to terms with the atrocities that were done in their name. Did they really not know are their hands clean, or were they just diluting themselves into thinking that their government was really just trying to keep them safe from communism? The whole idea of apartheid is the compartmentalization of South African thinking. “There were two South Africas: White and Black. Similarly, there was the public world and a private world, the open and the covert” (p. 108). All of this was rigidly separated. The white South African bystanders were able to live with the brutality against blacks because it was carried out in relative secret (p. 109). It was only when the truth came out that some people could not live with it, but then the silence wasmaintained for the greater good (p. 109).

In the book A Human Being Died that Night, Pumla Gonbodo-Madolozela’s goes on a road trip with her sister to see the infamous Vlakplaas. Vlakplaas is a farm just outside of Pretoria, also known as the death farm, where Eugene de Kock and his cronies did some of their crimes during apartheid. Pumla drove there using a map that de Kock had drawn for her in one of her meetings with him at the prison. However, as her sister pointed out, they were getting lost with his directions. The question arises as to whether or not he really wanted to give her the directions, for her to be able to go and see the place where he committed deeds that he his now deeply sorry for, the possibility that her visiting this place would make his crimes more real for her and sway her to the position of not seeing him as a humanworthy of forgiveness. Or he could just be really bad at giving directions.

Either way they had to stop and ask for directions. Pumla “approached a young woman behind the cash register and asked if she could please direct us to Vlakplaas” (p. 104). The young woman asked back “You mean the Vlakpaas?” with a nervous laugh, then she points to the older woman whom she had been speaking to. The older woman explained that her and her sister often walked through one section of the farm. “But they knew nothing about what had gone on during those early years – about what had now come out in the papers” (p.105). In fact this lady with a heavy German accent and her sister wished to buy a whole section of Vlakplaas, and turn it into a game reserve. She knew there were still bodies buried there but she believes that the beauty of deer frolicking wouldgive them a chance to rest in peace. How could these women not know what had gone on there? They were their neighbors, how could they have not seen or heard something to even hint at the dark deeds that were going on in side. I guess sometimes we humans don’t even see what is right in front of us, unless we are ready to accept the consequences.

This lack of knowledge is reiterated as Pumla and her sister drove through the final suburb before reaching Vlakpaas. She stopped and asked an Indian couple standing in their garden for directions to Vlakpaas. They told her that they “never heard of it” (p.106). They were literally seven minutes away and these people had never heard of it either as the death farm or as a legitimate farm. How could these people never hear of their grizzly neighbor? It was probably the only way they can cope with all that has happened, to make it apart from them. If they know nothing about it, then they could not have done something to stop it.

Finally Pumla arrived at the section of Vlakpaas that she was seeking. It was sealed off behind a tall fence with a large gate, a pack of bulldogs charged aggressively. A woman stood back as a young black man approached them. They told Pumla that she had to make an appointment to come and visit, nothing left to do she left.

These ordinary citizens were not the only ones who have separated out their existence from the atrocities that was done in their name. The man who came to be known as “Prime Evil”, Eugene de Kock also possesses this apartheid of the mind. Of separating out his family life from the work he did at Vlakpaas and the over boarder raids. He tells Pumla “It was hell. But they never knew” (p. 107). He talks about being afraid all the time, caring a firearm with him at all times even when he was out with his family. “I was afraid of my own people, my own people, because now they knew where I was, where I worked, when I left home, and where I would be at a specific time (pp 107-108). His children thought he was a business man, for they never saw him in a uniform like the otherpolicemen that they saw. To this day de Kock won’t divulge where his wife and children have relocated to, to protect them. For when your roles are reversed, according to de Kock “What has happened to your enemy can happen to you if you become the enemy” (p. 107)

Images found at the following:

http://www.cnn.com/WORLD/9610/30/s.africa

http://www.artthrob.co.za/01june/reviews.html

http://www.artthrob.co.za/01july/news.html

**********************************************************************

Sunday, November 2, 2008

What Makes Us Evil?

In our everyday lives do we ever stop to question if our actions are for the good of our lives and those around us or if they are evil? If these deeds that we think are good are really evil deeds. That we are not in the right but that who we perceive as our enemy is in fact in the right. This notion of good and evil is addressed in Pumla Gonbodo-Madolozela’s book A Human Being Died that Night. This story is about South Africa and the forgiveness involved in the post-apartheid era.

What is the nature of evil? How does a person like you or me become evil? Where is the line that separates good from evil. “It is this sense of a paper-thin line that is most frightening and most discomforting about those moments when our lives connect, however remotely, with the lives of people who have committed evil deeds.” (pp 50) Do we as a society try and explain this through the concept of mental illness. Does this comfort us to believe that these people are sick? However, “it has often been said that most of the people who commit human rights abuses are not psychopaths.” (pp52) But they do have to suppress there conscience somehow to allow themselves to commit horrible acts against others.

One view is that people who suffer at an early age can be predisposed to the establishment or basis for a life long pattern of revenge-based behavior. That their behavior is an endless cycle of violent behavior aimed at relieving unresolved feelings of being humiliated. This view would partially excuse Eugene de Kock, in some sense he might have had little choice in the human being that he became. But then if he was not in control of the actions he did, than how could we trust that he would not do them again. Would this line of thinking just lead us to the conclusion that he is evil, even if he did not choose to be. On the other hand some believe the sovereignty of the heart is essentially inviolable. “And though the decision to pursue what is right may on occasion be horrendously difficult, not only canpeople choose not to commit evil, but also they can make the kinds of choices that later on make it easier to avoid committing evil.” (pp 56) So even if he was abused as a child he was born to be evil. But eventually we realize that this issue is more complex than these two theories even come close to touching. The reality for de Kock is that he never denied what he did and he is now serving 2 life sentences for his actions during apartheid.

But what of the people who told de Kock what to do. He didn’t just wake up one morning and decided to become a murder, involved in the up keep of apartheid rule. The leaders of the South African government place all the blame on men like de Kock and his band of men, the foot soldiers, for all the atrocities of apartheid. They label them bad apples. In an address at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government F.W. de Klerk said that “my hands are clean” of the crimes committed by de Kock and the others. “In a ‘state of war’ foot soldiers in their zeal often go beyond what is legally acceptable and commit acts that are not authorized by the government.” (pp 60) The apartheid politicians never denied that what was done was criminal they denied that they were ever involved or knew anything about it.

This state of denial of the blame for apartheid is in direct contrast to the way that the leaders of Nazi Germany came to terms with the crimes committed under their regime. “The Nazis never denied involvement in what they had ordered, supported, or encouraged. What they denied was that it was criminal. ” (pp 66) So which leadership type betrays the greatest level of depravity? Personally I believe the depravity lays more with the ones who deny their involvement. For they feel the guilt and know that they were wrong but they continue to do it anyways and hope that they either never get caught or if they do they have distanced themselves far enough away that no on put the blame on them. But in the end either way it is horrific. Governments are put into place to protect the people not to harm them, but as weknow this is not always the case.

Images found at the following:

http://www.yebobooks.com/biographies-memoirs-c-21.html

http://www.cnn.com/WORLD/9610/30/s.africa

Sunday, October 26, 2008

We all have good and evil in us

Has some one ever hurt you, harmed you in some way that has changed who you are irrevocably. How did you deal with it? Did you confront your enemy? Did you wish them dead? Or did you try to forgive them and to move forward with you life? But you are just one person now how does a nation come to terms with the oppression and the heinous acts that were the repercussions of a complete policy of racial separateness? That is what South Africa had to face and why they formed the Truth and Reconciliation committee (TRC). The book A Human Being Died that Night by Pumla Gobodo-Madikizela is about her experiences in the post apartheid era as a member of the TRC and her interviews with a manreferred to as “prime evil”.

Apartheid came into existence in 1948, as a result of several political moves aimed at removing blacks not just from constitutional politics but from citizenship itself (pp 143). The national party’s bedrock goal was racial, cultural, and political purity (pp144). This goal was accomplished through several acts passed by the congress. The effect was not only to legalize all forms of discrimination against black, but to disenfranchise blacks and reduce them to second-class citizens (pp144). In 1912 the African National Congress (ANC) was formed on a campaign for non-racial democracy and human rights, which black people were denied in the colonial era (pp144).

These two parties came to a head in an event that shocked the world, on March 21, 1960, when several thousand unarmed black people gathered in the Vereeninging township of Shaepeville and marched on the police station to protest the hated pass laws, and the police opened fire in the crowd (pp144). The response was swift by the government banning all anti-apartheid organizations and then passing laws exonerating police from responsibility in acts committed against those involved (pp145). In this atmosphere of total white freedom, is where Eugene de Kock came to be who he is known to be today “prime evil”.

“When violators of human rights allow themselves to be emotionally vulnerable, they are giving others a chance to encounter them as human beings. When this happens, it is inevitable for one to wonder: If they can feel like human beings, if they can share a human moment with those on whom they inflicted trauma, pain, misery, why did the good side of humanity fail when it was needed most?” (pp16) This is one of many questions Pumla asks herself. Where did their humanity go and can they ever get it back?

A prime example is with psychological experiments in our own country into the mob mentality, where ordinary college students were turned into prisoners and prison guards. The guards took their positions so seriously that they began to abuse the prisoners and to violate their rights. This shows us how easily a normal human being can turn into a monster if given the right circumstances. And those circumstances where present for de Kock. He did some pretty heinous crimes against humanity during the apartheid regime. But do these crimes mean that he can never come back to his humanity. That his humanity is lost to him forever and he should always be punished. Some believe this to be true and that is why he is imprisoned for life every time he appeals the sentence it is turned down.

But in order to commit the crimes he did, he would have had to put aside his humanity, or at least the part that sees others as humans. In war one is taught to dehumanize the enemy it makes it easier (not easy) to commit the acts you have to against them if they are less than you are. That does not mean that you are less human and that you have lost your humanity but it does mean that you have to live with the memories of these acts for the rest of your life when you come back to the realization that they were human.

Morally I believe that we all possess the potential for great good and for great evil, given the proper circumstances. I would like to believe that I could not have done the things that de Kock has done but ultimately until I walk in his shoes I can not know for certain. I feel that the African concept of Ubuntu, (my humanity is strengthened by embracing your humanity) is appropriate for this situation where when all is said and done these people the victims and the oppressors have to live together and form a new nation, it’s not like you can send one part away, or punish all of the white people of the nation. But only time will tell how well this healing method works for South Africa.

Images found at the following:

http://www.embassyworld.com/maps/Maps_Of_South_Africa.html

http://www.usip.org/fellows/reports/2004/0429_shaw.html

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2008/10/20/truth-resignation.html?ref=rss

Sunday, October 19, 2008

A Woman's Worth

What is a woman’s worth? Is it based on how society sees her, how men see her, how her parents or relatives see her, or how she sees herself? Nawal El Saadawi’s Woman at Point Zero shows me a world very much unlike my own. This book makes me see the suffering endured by women that has occurred in the past and that still is happening in some parts of the world today. It makes my heart ache, I want to jump up and shout about the injustices. To tell these women that they can get out, that they can change their world for the better, they just have to try.

This novel about a woman in Egypt who feels she is powerless to change her status in the society. Her whole life, the main character Firdaus, is used and abused by the men in her life. One day as she talks to one of her male “friends” he tells her that she is not respectable. Up to this point she had not valued her self and she had just finally recognized that she was worth something. Even if it was to ask for more money from a man who wished to have intercourse with her. She was happier than she had ever been in her life, but all that came crashing down with that little phrase ‘not respectable’. To cope with this new knowledge she quit her profession and went out into the world to become a respectable woman.

Firdaus finds a job at a company, it is not mentioned what the company is only that she doesn’t make very much money. The men in the company frequently harass the women and the women would use their bodies to procure advances in the company. At one point in time a man higher up in the company asked her if she wanted a ride. Firdaus replied “The price of my body is much higher than the price that can be paid for it with a pay raise.” After about three years of working there she realized that as a prostitute she was paid more, had more respect and overall lived a better life. “I came to realize that a female employee is more afraid of losing her job than a prostitute is of losing her life.”

This woman began to pity the other women employees and to view her old life as better. “An employee is scared of losing her job and becoming a prostitute because she does not understand that the prostitute’s life is in fact better than hers.” Firdaus’s realization was that a woman employee pays a much higher price “of her illusory fears” than Firdaus ever did, with “her life, her health, her body, and her mind. She pays the highest price for things of the lowest value.”

“I now knew that all of us were prostitutes who sold themselves at varying prices, and that an expensive prostitute was better than a cheap one.” Is this really true are all women prostitutes, do we all sell ourselves for the things that we get? Firdaus grew up in a world where women were treated like second class citizens, where a husband was expected to beat his wife and there was nothing wrong with it, where women were expected to be subjugated to men in every way. But just as Firdaus said that she had not meet every man who photo she spat upon, she could not have meet every woman, or even every woman that worked at the company that she worked for. How can she make this sweeping accusation? But that was her view of the world around her, she did not know of any women who had broken free of this oppression from the menaround them. Maybe if she had things would have gone better in the rest of her life.

This was the point were she starts to give up her dream of being a respectable woman and to go back her old life. “I also knew that if I lost my job, all I would lose with it was the miserable salary, the contempt I could read every day in the eyes of the higher level executives when they looked at the lesser female officials, the humiliating pressure of male bodies on mine when I rode in the bus, and the long morning queue in front of a perpetually overflowing toilet.” But she stuck it out for a little bit longer, it took getting involved with a man whom she fell in love with to break her heart to force her to completely give up and go back to prostitution.

For some time after wards she was successful as a prostitute, until a day came where a man wanted to be her pimp and forced himself upon her. When she could no longer stand his oppressive presence in her life she tries to run away from him only for him to stop her in the act and try to harm her. She kills him in self defense, but that does not matter for now she knows that she is capable of murder. After wards she is arrested. “They condemned me to death not because I had killed a man, but because they are afraid to let me live.” In the end I believe that she had finally found her own peace in herself, but that she was never free of the trappings from the life she had lived.

Images found at the following:

http://story.heraldglobe.com/index.php/ct/9/cid/b8de8e630faf3631/id/7787205

http://www.middle-east-online.com/ENGLISH/features?id=12928

http://speakingoffaith.publicradio.org/programs/muslimwomen/matar-intro.shtml

http://www.boston.com/news/world/middleeast/articles/2005/07/25/egypt_police_sketch_outlines_of_resort_attacks?mode=PF

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/896930.stm

Sunday, October 12, 2008

Who is Nawal El Saadawi?

Who is Nawal El Saadawi? Have you not heard of her? I know I had not, until I was exposed to her writing in my English class. We were assigned to read her novel Woman at Point Zero. Nawal El Saadawi is a novelist and a psychiatrist. She was imprisoned in 1981 for her political views on women’s rights and was released only after President Sadat was assonated. After her time in prison she realized that one person could be silenced but not a whole organization. So she set out to start the Arab Women’s Solidarity Association.

Woman at Point Zero is a tale of a woman and her life that lead up to the point where she was going to be executed for murder. This woman named Firdaus was born in a rural village in Egypt. From an early age she is forced to be oppressed by the males in her life. She sees her mother beaten for the deaths of her brothers by her father, but nothing is done for the deaths of her sisters. She feels that the man who is her father is not her father and one day she asks her mother “How was it that she had given birth to me without a father?” Her mother than beat her and “then she brought a women who was caring a small knife or maybe a razor blade. They cut off a piece of flesh from between my thighs.” This experience ofgenital mutilation has an impact on her for the rest of her life.

Her uncle sends her to elementary school after her father dies and the she goes to live with her uncle in Cairo after her mother dies. She feels as if she is reborn into a new life in the city. But she doesn’t know who she is. At some point it is indicated that her uncle probably took her innocence and that changed their relationship. He then married and they all moved into a house. His new wife did not like Firdaus and they sent her way to attend secondary school. St this school she meets a teacher who resonates in her this need for a mother figure. But in the end she has to go back to her uncle’s house, where she is not welcome. Her uncle and his wife marry her off to an older relative. He beats herand treats her badly. So she runs away.

Firdaus is now on the streets and is scared. A man who seems to be nice takes her home with him, but he just ends up using her like all the other men in her life. His name was Bayoumi and he “took to locking Firdaus in the flat before going out.” He then starting letting his friends come over and abuse her. “One day a neighbor saw her through the lattice of the door as she stood there weeping. She asked her what was wrong, so Firdaus told her.” The woman got a carpenter to free her and she ran as fast as she could away from there.

When she stopped it was in a park where a woman names Sharifa found her. Sharifa although not a good person as she made money off of Firdaus, laid the ground work down for Firdaus to start valuing herself, for her to see herself as something or someone of worth. This is a main theme in the book, that the women have to value themselves before men will ever value them.

Now this all sounds like Nawal El Saadawi had a hard life if this the type of novel she would write. But she writes to help other women see the oppression around them. In an interview with Miriam Cooke from Duke University she explains how her grandmother had a huge impact on her. This woman who never read a book was a strong woman and was into the local politics. She raised her son to be a good man, and father. Unlike the characters in her books Nawal El Saadawi had a good relationship with her father. Her father never was cruel or disrespectful of her mother and this relationship help to shape this woman to make her go one to become a doctor, and to later fight for the human rights of women in Egypt.

Even to this day Nawal El Saadawi is fighting to go home to her native country to help the oppressed women there see their worth. She has been exiled from her home land and has fought for her books to not be banned from there. In May of this year she won a case that was filed against her to deprive her of her nationality. The court handed down that the law doesn’t allow lifting nationality for holding controversial thoughts or different creed. Though she is still waiting to go home until she feels it is safe for her to return.

For more information about Nawal El Saadawi go to her websites:

http://www.nawalsaadawi.net/bio.html#saadawi

http://www.nawalsaadawi.net/oldsite/index.html

Here is also the link to the interview with Miriam Cooke at Duke University:

http://www.duke.edu/web/muslimnets/mcw_bio/

Images found at the following:

http://lexicorient.com/e.o/saadawi.htm

http://www.middleeasterndance.homestead.com/WAPZ.html

http://www.middle-east-online.com/english?id=16563

http://www.nawalsaadawi.net/oldsite/bio.htm

http://www-english.tamu.edu/pers/fac/muana/archivefem.htm

http://www.mideastyouth.com/2007/04/28/the-2007-lets-get-free-mideast-pageant


Sunday, October 5, 2008

Changez Changes His Janissiary Way of Life

Have you ever felt as if you are living in two worlds. That you do the things you do because you have to, but your heart is elsewhere. This feeling of being two faced or Janus faced is sometimes easy and at other time most difficult. In Mohsin Hamid’s The Reluctant Fundamentalist, the main character Changez is struggling with this notion.


Changez feels as if he has split loyalties, on the one hand he is living the American Dream in America, he has a good education and a great job with a large income to match, but at the same time America is at war with people on his mother continent. As he goes off on another assignment for the company he works for to Valparaiso, Chile he is in great turmoil. In Chile, Underwood Samson is evaluating a book publisher for there client a potential buyer of the publisher. In this place Changez’s world really starts to come apart at the seams. He realizes, “as for myself, I was clearly on the threshold of great change; only the final catalyst was now required, and in my case that catalyst took the form of lunch.”

This lunch was with the chief of the publishing company, Juan-Bautista. This old man told Changez the story about the janissaries. Juan-Bautista explains ‘they were Christian boys, captured by the Ottomans and trained to be soldiers in a Muslim army, at that time the greatest army in the world. They were ferocious and utterly loyal; they had fought to erase their own civilizations, so they had nothing else to turn to.’ Changez soon realizes that he “was a modern-day janissary, a servant of the American empire at a time when it was invading a country with a kinship to mine and was perhaps even colluding to ensue that my own country faced the threat of war.” After this turning point, this realization that he could not go on living in this world of dividedloyalties. Changez quit his job and returned to New York. “Thank you, Juan-Bautista, I thought as I lay myself down in my bed, for helping me to push back the veil behind which all this had been concealed!”

At this point Changez has only one thing keeping him in America the thought of Erica by his side. He went to the institution where he had gone to visit her and she was gone. Disappeared, no one had seen or heard from her since he had last visited. Changez went immediately to her mother, no one believed that Erica would ever be found again. Her mother gave Changez her manuscript, once he read it he “could not locate Erica in the rhythms or sounds of what she had written.” As he put down the manuscript he “had begun to understand that she had chosen not to be part of my story; her own had proven too compelling, and she was – at the moment and in her own way – following it to its conclusion, passing through places I could not reach.” He now had no option but to prepare toleave.

In the end, Changez was relieved to no longer have to be a janissary. He now only had one loyalty and that was to his mother land, though he still felt a connection to America through his emotional connection to his lost love, Erica. As he began his new life as a university lecturer, he made it his mission on campus was “to advocate a disengagement from” America and Pakistan. He encouraged his students to participate in demonstrations for “greater independence in Pakistan’s domestic and international affairs”, which later were labeled anti-American.

Images found at the following sites:

http://people.brandeis.edu/~nika/chile/valparaiso


http://www.janissary.info/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/infliximab/325668658/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/anthony_mitchell/2201987472/